Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting

Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting // The Sugar Hit


Remember when cupcakes were nothing? Before they became first a food fetish, and then a craft project, and then a totally played out fad? Remember when muffins were the thing that was everywhere? It was a long time ago, so you’ll probably have to think back. Nirvana was big, Starbucks was new and and muffins-only muffin chains were popping up everywhere. This was before everyone caught onto the idea that muffins were just pretty huge cakes, and therefore a fairly horrendously caloric snack/breakfast.


Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting // The Sugar Hit


Anyway, it’s the nineties/early noughties and muffins are big business. ‘Muffin men’ becomes the new term for fat cats – just kidding, not really, but wouldn’t it be great if that were true? So muffins are cruising along, everyone thinks muffins can never be knocked off their pedestal and then BOOM Carrie Bradshaw comes along with her Magnolia Bakery cupcake and destroys everything muffins thought they knew. Suddenly cupcakes are up on top, their whorls of pink frosting towering over the single-serving dessert industry.


Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting // The Sugar Hit


And then it got really boring really quick. The actual cupcakes were just never that good. Very sweet, yes. Buckets of frosting, yes. But no really uh-mazing shiz. No-one out there Dominique Ansel-ing themselves. For the most part the focus of cupcakers seemed to be on how cute they could make their cupcakes, and not how delicious. Thank goodness the craze is over, and now, tentatively, we can start actually trying to make really really good cupcakes again. Enter, these Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting.


Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting // The Sugar Hit


These are what I always wanted my chocolate cupcake to be. Not a dry, barely chocolate at all cake, stoically bearing the weight of a mountain of tooth-achingly sugary frosting. No. Instead, these are a verrrry moist, complex, intriguing cake, being set off and smokily partnered by the most delicious flipping frosting you’ve ever had. The cupcake is a chocolate rye cake, using rye flour for half the flour component and featuring buttermilk and olive oil in the batter. The result is an intriguing, complex, smoky cake, but it’s actually just incredibly chocolate-y. I’m not sure you would notice the other ingredients (read: you could feed these to children/picky eaters). But since you do know about them, you notice the tang and tannin of the rye, and the slight bitterness of the olive oil.


Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting // The Sugar HitChocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting // The Sugar Hit


The frosting is another level all together. Using a kilo of frosting to ice 12 cakes can get booted. Buttercream has its place, sure, but this cooked pudding-like frosting is my new best friend and I want to put it on everything. It literally tastes just like thick, lush, sensual chocolate pudding, and it sets off the smoky-toned cakes perfectly. I added sprinkles, because of course, and there you have it. In my house, cupcakes are officially back.


xx Sarah.


Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting // The Sugar Hit


Chocolate Rye Cupcakes with Chocolate Pudding Frosting
Serves: 12 cupcakes.
For the cupcakes:
  • ½ cup (75g) dark rye flour
  • ½ cup (75g) plain flour
  • 1 cup (200g) caster sugar
  • ⅓ cup (35g) cocoa powder
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • ½ tsp baking soda
  • pinch of salt
  • ½ cup (125ml) buttermilk
  • ½ cup (125ml) light olive oil
  • 1 egg
  • ¼ cup (65ml) hot water
For the frosting:
  • 1 cup (200g) caster sugar
  • 4½ tbsp cornflour (cornstarch in you're in the USA)
  • 1½ tbsp cocoa
  • 1 tbsp chocolate malt powder (aka ovaltine)
  • 100g (4oz) milk chocolate, chopped
  • 1 cup (250ml) boiling water
  • 150g (1 stick + 4 tbsp) butter, softened
  1. Line a cupcake tray with cupcake papers and preheat the oven to 180C/350F.
  2. In a large bowl, sift together all the dry ingredients.
  3. In a separate pitcher, whisk together the buttermilk, oil and egg. Whisk into the dry ingredients until smooth, then finally, whisk in the hot water. The batter should be fairly liquid.
  4. Divide the batter evenly between the cupcake papers, and then bake for 17-20 minutes, or until risen, and springing back when touched. Remove from the tray and set on a rack to cool completely.
  5. To make the frosting, place the sugar, cornflour, cocoa, malt and chocolate into a saucepan and pour over 1 cup freshly boiled water. Whisk everything until combined and smooth, and then place over a high heat.
  6. Bring the mixture to the boil, stirring and scraping the bottom, to make sure it's not sticking. Cook until the mixture thickens up, or about 1-2 minutes after it boils. It should be very thick.
  7. Remove the mixture from the heat, and scrape into the bowl of a standing mixer. Using the paddle attachment, beat the mixture on a low speed until it has cooled COMPLETELY. And I mean completely - if it's warm, it's too hot.
  8. Once the mixture is seriously cooled, add in the softened butter and beat until incorporated - you should have a fairly soft, thick, shiny frosting. If it's warm where you are, you might need to throw it in the fridge for a while to firm up at this point.
  9. Spread the frosting over the cupcakes in whatever way you like decorate with sprinkles, and serve!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.